Why You're Gaining Weight When Eating Less & Working Out

Why You're Gaining Weight When Eating Less & Working Out

Ever find yourself stepping on the scale and wondering why the numbers keep creeping up, even though you've been religiously sticking to your salad lunches and gym routines? It’s a head-scratcher, right? 

At My Fit Foods, we get it — eating less and working out more sounds like a foolproof formula for weight loss. But sometimes, your body hasn't quite gotten the memo. 

Interested in discovering more? We’ve got you covered. Read on to get the scoop on why you might be gaining weight despite your best efforts to lose it. 

Why Might You Gain Weight Despite Fewer Calories and Exercise?

So, you're hitting the gym on the reg, cutting back on calories, but the scale isn't budging — or worse, it's creeping upward. What gives?

Calorie Quality Over Quantity

Think you're eating less? It might be time to look not just at how many calories there are but also at what types of calories are consumed; not all calories are created equal. A calorie from an apple influences your body differently than a calorie from a sugary treat, affecting everything from your blood sugar to your satiety levels. 

Whole foods packed with fiber and nutrients support a healthy weight, while processed foods can lead to weight gain, even if they're low in calories, due to their impact on cravings and blood sugar levels.

Muscle Mass vs. Fat

If your workouts have gotten more intense or you've recently taken up strength training, you might actually be gaining muscle mass. Muscle is more dense than fat, so it weighs more by volume. This type of weight gain is actually beneficial and means you’re improving your body composition — even if it doesn’t immediately show as weight loss on your scale.

Cortisol

Intense physical activity, especially high-intensity workouts, can temporarily spike your cortisol levels. When elevated, cortisol can cause the body to retain water, leading to fluid retention and a temporary increase in body weight. 

Thyroid and Hormonal Balance

Sometimes, the issue is more than skin deep. Hormonal imbalances, including thyroid issues, can profoundly affect your metabolism and lead to weight gain. If you suspect a medical condition is derailing your weight loss efforts, it’s wise to consult a healthcare provider or a registered dietitian who can offer tailored advice and possible treatments.

Sleep

Underestimating the power of a good night's sleep? Think again. Lack of quality sleep can mess with your hormones — particularly ghrelin and leptin, which regulate hunger and fullness. If you’re not getting enough sleep, your body might crave more food and store more fat, derailing your weight loss goals.

Hydration and Water Weight

Believe it or not, not drinking enough water can lead your body to hold onto it, leading to water retention. Make sure you’re hydrating properly to help your body maintain a balance of fluids.

How Can You Differentiate Between Fat Loss, Muscle Gain, and Water Weight?

Deciphering the changes on your scale can be tricky. Are you shedding fat, building muscle, or is it just fluctuations in water weight? 

Here are some clear indicators to help you figure out exactly what's happening with your weight.

Dive Into Body Composition

Skip the regular scales and use a body composition monitor instead. These devices give you a clearer picture by showing how much of your weight is fat versus muscle. If you’re gaining muscle, your overall weight might not drop significantly — even if you're losing fat.

Track the Tape

Use a tape measure to track changes in your body's circumference. If you're losing inches around your waist but your weight stays the same, it's likely you're gaining muscle while losing fat.

Gauge Your Gains

How's your gym game? If you’re lifting heavier or sprinting faster, it's a good sign that you're building muscle. Muscle weighs more than fat and boosts your metabolism, too — hello, fitness gains.

Watch for Water Works

Weight that comes and goes like a spring shower could be water. Eating salty snacks or hormonal shifts can have you holding onto fluids one day and losing them the next. Notice your weight bouncing around after a big meal or during your cycle? That’s likely water weight.

Sense Your Strength and Stamina

Lastly, how do you feel overall? More energy and better overall health are signs of positive physical changes. If you’re feeling sluggish, it might be time to adjust your calorie intake or sleep schedule.

Ready To Optimize Your Body Composition?

Getting your body composition right involves more than just watching what you eat and sticking to your workout routine. 

Here are some practical tips to help you support and improve your body composition for a healthier lifestyle.

Strength Training Is Key

Adding weights to your workout plan is one of the best ways to build muscle mass. Muscle burns more calories than fat, even at rest, which can help support your weight loss goals. Aim for a mix of strength training exercises two to three times a week for the best results.

Keep Meal Timing Consistent

Eating meals at regular intervals each day can help balance blood sugar and prevent cravings. When your eating schedule is on point, it’s easier to avoid late-night snacking or overeating, making it simpler to stick to a healthy diet.

Stay Hydrated

Water retention can be mistaken for weight gain, so make sure you’re drinking enough water to keep things balanced. Staying hydrated also supports your muscles and joints and can help keep cravings at bay. Keep a water bottle on hand and refill throughout the day.

Focus on Protein

Protein is essential for muscle repair and maintenance. Lean proteins like chicken, fish, and legumes should be part of every meal to help you stay satisfied and keep those muscles fueled.

Make Meal Prep Easy

When you have meals ready to go, sticking to your nutrition plan becomes a no-brainer. My Fit Foods has your back here with meals that are balanced and convenient. Check out options like our Turkey Roll-Up or the Beef Pot Roast — both are packed with nutrients and are easy to grab when you’re short on time.

Get Quality Sleep

Quality sleep helps regulate cortisol levels and is essential for muscle recovery. Aim for seven to eight hours per night for men. For women, it’s best to aim for nine to 10 hours a night! Better rest means better workouts, a sharper focus, and better choices throughout the day.

Manage Stress Levels

High stress can affect body fat retention, particularly around the belly. Find a way to de-stress that works for you — whether that’s a walk, a good book, or deep breathing exercises. Lowering stress is good for both mental health and body composition.

Watch Your Portions

Keeping portions in check is key — even with healthy foods, too much can slow down progress. That’s where our meals come in handy. Each of our meals at My Fit Foods is perfectly portioned to balance nutrients and calories, so you don’t have to guess. Whether it’s our Wake N’ Steak or Orange Chicken, you’re getting just the right amount to support your goals without overdoing it.

Conclusion

So, why might you be gaining weight when you’re eating less and working out? It could be anything from building muscle mass, retaining water, or dealing with hormonal factors to simple changes in routine. 

Remember, healthy body composition isn’t all about the scale — it’s about how you feel and finding what works for you. If you’re ready to simplify meal planning and focus on balanced, portioned meals, we’re here to help. 

With My Fit Foods, you can pick up fresh, ready-made meals designed to support your goals. Stop by one of our locations or browse our options online, and let’s make healthy eating easy as pie!

Sources:

What Is Calorie Deficit? | Cleveland Clinic

Fluid imbalance | Caloric | MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia

Tips to Reduce Cortisol Levels and Dial Down Stress | Cleveland Clinic

Obesity and hormones | Better Health Channel

Muscle cells vs. fat cells | MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia 

Back to blog